Characters:
1. What are
the names of the two main characters of the movie?
They are William of Baskerville and Adso of Melk
2. What
religious order do they belong to? Who founded the order and what the order’s
key principles?
They belong to the Franciscan religious order, founded
by Saint Francis of Assisi. They defend, mainly, the poverty of Christ.
3. What other
famous pair in the crime novel could you compare them with?
I think William of Baskerville and Adso have some
similarities with Sherlock Holmes and Watson: William analyzes the clues of the
crime, and Adso is his assistant, similar to the British Sherlock and Watson.
4. Why do
these two characters go this Abbey in northern Italy?
They go there to debate whether Christ lived in
poverty or not.
5. What are
the secret instruments that Brother William carries? Why did he cover them when
he received the Abbot’s visit in his cell?
He was taking out of his bag a star meter and a sand
clock, and he covered them with a blanket when he heard the Abbot’s steps. He hide them because he could get into trouble because he wasn't really faithful and a strong believer. Instead, he wanted to see something else.
6. Which of
the two theological current, Patristics or Scholasticism would you identify
Brother William with? Why?
He is from the Shcolasticism, because he likes to compaginate the religious believes with the search of reason, as he always wants to find a logical answer to everything, like the murders.
7. Which
character in the film would oppose, from the theological-philosophical point of
view of Bro. William?
George of Burgos. While Bro. William defends certain
ideas such as laughter, George disregards and hate on them.
8. The
character of Bro. William is inspired of William of Ockham. Finde some
information about this character and his philosophy
William of Ockham was a Franciscan and philosopher,
born in Surrey (England) in the 13th Century. He was “the most
nominalist person ever”. His ideas (from the nominalism) oppose to the
existence of the universal concepts neither in the reality nor in the people’s
mind.
9. What does
the peasant girl symbolize? What vision existed for women and love in the Middle
Ages according to the film?
According to the film, the girl symbolizes the
temptation and the evil. It was thought that women were distraction and bad
things.
10. Who were
the “Dulcinians” or “Dulcinites”?
The Dulcinans were people, considered despicable, that
stole from the rich to give it to the poor. In the film, Remigio took the food
from the abbey to give it back to the peasants.
Which
characters in the film practiced the heresy?
Apart from Remigio considered heretic, Salvatore also
practiced heresy
Abbey:
1.
What monastic order does the abbey belong to?
The monks from the abbey are
Benedictins.
2.
Who founded this order and what was their motto?
Its founder is Benit from
Nursy. The motto that can be seen in the scriptorium is "ora e labora", but the real benedictins motto is "do not put anything before God's love".
3.
What activities take place in the monastery?
God is prayed, livestock
raised, books copied…
4.
Why do the peasants go to the abbey? What were the
social groups in the Middle Ages and what was their role in society?
Peasants go to the Abbey to
pay the tithe to the monks (10% of the harvest). In the Middle Ages, during
feudalism, peasants were the main supply of food for the rest of the states.
5.
What architectural style appears in the movie? And
what are its main characteristics?
In the movie, it appears
Romanesque in the Abbey and other buildings. The Romanesque is spiritual and
dark, as it depicts the fear and respect to god. The churches are small, dark,
with few windows, round arches and canon vault.
6.
Does the Abbey that inspired the novel still exist?
Where is it?
Yes, the Saint Michael of
Chiesa abbey really exists. It is on the Pirichiarno Mountain in Italy, some
kilometers away from Rome.
The story
1.
After the first deaths, what book of the Bible seems
to answer to those inexplicable murders? Why?
It was the apocalypse book,
because year 1000 was close and because all deaths looked like they were
similar to the predictions and storyline that this book of the Bible says.
2.
What is the debate that occurs in the Abbey about?
The debate was about the
poverty of Christ (if Christ lived in poverty or not)
3.
Why Pontifical Delegates were sent to participate in
this debate?
Because they were the rivals of the franciscans in the debate about the poverty of Christ. The Pontifical Delegates defend that the Church should keep it's wealth.
4.
What are the two opposing argument that mark the
debate?
One of the arguments is that
the Church should be poor and give its possessions to the most needed, as
Christ did. The other argument claims that if the Church is poor, it will have
nothing to fight the unfaithful.
5.
What does Bernardo Gui symbolize? Did he really exist?
Bernardo Gui symbolizes the
Inquisition and the most conservative and assertive face of the Church. He
really existed. He was a French Dominique and Inquisitor who wrote a book about
inquisition and heresy.
6.
What was the Holy Inquisition?
It was a Christian religious
organization that was in charge of controlling what is said about religion, to
censure blasphemy and to fight heresy.
7.
What tricks are used by the Director to keep the
plot’s intrigue and the viewer’s attention?
He tries to confuse the
viewer, making him doubt which one of the ugly monks is the bad one. Also,
constant killings and the small guiltiness of the monks are showed to keep the
intrigue.
8.
What does ugliness symbolize in the movie?
It symbolizes everything evil
and non-religious. The ugly monks have bad intentions behind and make the
viewer see them as suspects of the crimes of the Abbey.
The books
1. What
classical authors is Bro. William “in love” with?
He says he is in love with the Greek philosopher Aristotle
and with the Roman writers Ovidio and Virgilio.
2. What do
these authors have in common?
They are all from the Greco-Latin
culture and literature
3. What
opposing arguments about laughter appear in the movie?
George of Burgos says that
laughter is an evil thing that makes men look like monkeys. He also says that
Christ never laughed.
4.
What forbidden book used humor and comedy as an
instrument of truth?
It was Aristotle second poetic
book, which was lost centuries ago and was dedicated to humor as an instrument
of truth
5.
Why did Venerable Jorge poison the tips of that book’s
pages?
Because he hated laughter, and
that book was about comedy and humor. As a way to punish the sinners who read
the book, he poisoned the tips of the pages of the book, so when the reader
wets his fingers and touches it to move to the next page, he will make contact
with the poison.
6. Why did
Umberto Eco title his novel as The Name of the Rose?
He named it like that to make a reference to a Bernard
Gui’s poem. This poem says that in this imperfect world, the only things that
never die are ideas. This can be seen in the movie about the concepts of
laughter and the Inquisition.
Commentary
I found this film interesting
at first, but then it began to bore me out. I know it is very instructive: it
teaches history and makes the viewer think about the Inquisition and the ideas
of the time. However, it was very long for me, and in most parts I didn’t
really understand the plot and what was going on.